Overnight Health Care — Sponsored by Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids — Appeals court appears skeptical of upholding ObamaCare mandate | Drug pricing deal faces GOP pushback | Trump officials look for plan B after court strikes drug TV ad rule
Welcome to Tuesday’s Overnight Health Care.
Today was ObamaCare’s latest day in court. GOP senators are raising concerns over what could be a bipartisan drug pricing deal, and the Trump administration is looking for a way forward after a federal judge blocked a drug pricing rule.
We’ll start with ObamaCare:
Court appears uncertain on overturning ObamaCare
A federal appeals court on Tuesday hinted that they would strike down ObamaCare’s individual mandate as unconstitutional, but the three-judge panel was not as clear about whether they would overturn the entire law.
Two Republican-appointed judges on the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals grilled attorneys representing Democratic attorneys general about whether Congress intended to invalidate the entire law when lawmakers eliminated the penalty for the individual mandate.
The issue is whether the mandate can be separated from the rest of the law, which extends far beyond just health insurance.
“If you no longer have the tax why isn’t [the mandate] unconstitutional?” said Jennifer Elrod, who was appointed by former President George W. Bush.
California deputy attorney general Samuel Siegel argued that Congress did not want the Affordable Care Act to fall when it eliminated out the individual mandate penalty as part of the 2017 tax law.
“Members of Congress who voted for the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act said they were not repealing the ACA,” said a spokesperson for California Attorney General Xavier BecerraXavier BecerraDemocratic group hits GOP attorneys general in six-figure ad campaign on ObamaCare Overnight Energy: Democrats to vote on 2020 climate debate | Green groups sue to stop Keystone XL construction | States sue EPA for tougher rules on asbestos States sue EPA for tougher regulation of asbestos MORE, which is leading a coalition of blue states in defending the law.
Also at issue: The lead litigator for the individual plaintiffs in the case said he expects the judges to uphold the lower court’s ruling and also strike the Democratic states and the House of Representatives from the case.
(Remember, the court questioned last week whether the states and the House have legal standing to appeal the lower court’s ruling.)
“The trial court ruled in our favor, and it did not seem that the Fifth Circuit panel really had much disagreement with that,” said Robert Henneke.
“I expect after today’s arguments the Fifth Circuit will uphold the trial court decision and very likely the Fifth Circuit will strike the House of Representatives and California from the case.”
Read more here.
Sponsored Content: Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids
Don’t trust Juul: Stop flavored tobacco now.
Juul enticed kids with sweet flavors like mango, crème and mint, then hooked them with a strong nicotine hit. Last year, teen e-cigarette use spiked 78%. It’s an epidemic. Learn more.
GOP senators raise concerns over potential deal to lower drug prices
A potential bipartisan deal to lower drug prices is running into turbulence from some GOP senators.
Senate Finance Committee Chairman Chuck GrassleyCharles (Chuck) Ernest GrassleyGraham open to investigating Acosta-Epstein plea deal Taxpayer advocate heading to greener pastures GOP senators decline to criticize Acosta after new Epstein charges MORE (R-Iowa) held the meeting with GOP committee members to discuss a possible agreement that he has been negotiating for months with Sen. Ron WydenRonald (Ron) Lee WydenOvernight Health Care — Sponsored by Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids — Arguments in ObamaCare lawsuit begin Tuesday | What to expect in major test for health law | Democrats launch new blitz against GOP over lawsuit Cities lead crackdown on facial recognition tech Lawmakers grow impatient for FDA cannabis rules MORE (Ore.), the top Democrat on the panel.
But pushback from some in the GOP may pose an obstacle to a final breakthrough.
The sticking point: An idea pushed by Wyden that would limit the ability of drug companies to raise prices faster than inflation in Medicare’s prescription drug program, called Part D. Drug companies would have to pay money back to Medicare if their prices rose too quickly.
The question now: Is Grassley willing to push forward with this deal and risk losing some GOP senators?
Read more here.
Trump officials seek plan B on drug pricing rule
The Trump administration suffered a blow when a federal judge blocked a key rule about drug price disclosures just hours before it was scheduled to take effect and officials are now seeking a way forward.
U.S. District Judge Amit P. Mehta in Washington, D.C., on Monday sided with a coalition of drug companies and blocked the Trump administration from implementing a policy that would require prescription drug manufacturers to disclose list prices in TV ads. Mehta said the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) does not have the authority to compel drug companies to disclose prices.
Experts don’t believe the rule would have been very effective at lowering drug prices, but it was one of Trump’s highest-profile initiatives and the first policy released after the administration unveiled its drug pricing “blueprint” in 2018.
It is not immediately clear how the administration will proceed, but the ruling threatens to rob President TrumpDonald John TrumpGraham open to investigating Acosta-Epstein plea deal Sustaining progress with Mexico on migration Government to issue licenses for business with Huawei MORE of an important victory in the fight over drug costs.
One easy solution: Congress can give permission. Bipartisan legislation introduced by Senate Finance Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) and Sen. Dick DurbinRichard (Dick) Joseph DurbinDemocrats celebrate announcement on citizenship census question Politicians cheer USWNT over defeating England, qualifying for World Cup final Supreme Court stokes DACA fight for 2020 MORE (D-Ill.) would codify the HHS regulation into law. The bill could be added to a legislative package that Grassley is trying to push through the committee. A companion bill in the House is sponsored by Rep. Francis RooneyLaurence (Francis) Francis RooneyAddressing climate change is a win for Republicans — why not embrace it? Pricing carbon: A solution whose time has finally come Activists push for tougher sanctions on Nicaragua’s government MORE (R-Fla.).
Click Here: Sports Water Bottles
The legislation would have the same impact as the rule, which is to say, not much. But it’s a politically popular move.
Read more here.
ESPN’s Adam Schefter joins push for diabetes research
Celebrities dealing with Type 1 diabetes joined a town hall in Washington, D.C., on Tuesday to meet and inspire children who have the same condition.
The event was organized by the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation (JDRF), a group dedicated to providing support for those who have Type 1 diabetes as well as raising money and awareness. It featured athletes, actors and artists who spoke about their personal experiences with the disease and the obstacles they overcame.
Sports writer and ESPN analyst Adam Schefter moderated the town hall, which also included children with Type 1 diabetes. Schefter told the young people at the event that it was possible to be successful and manage their diabetes.
“You can still achieve your dreams,” he said.
The town hall is a part of the JDRF Children’s Congress, a weeklong event that brings more than 160 children from across the country with Type 1 diabetes to Washington every two years to meet with role models and push lawmakers to fund research.
More from the town hall here.
What we’re reading
Abortion arguments at play in limiting veterans’ IVF benefit (Associated Press)
Hundreds of hospice centers in US get failing grades (NBC)
Joe BidenJoe BidenTransgender activist Sarah McBride announces bid for Delaware state Senate Poll: Trump trails Biden and Sanders, beats Buttigieg, Harris, and Warren Democrats are too far left to win Middle America MORE on ObamaCare and Medicare for All: ‘Starting over would be, I think, a sin’ (CNN)
State by state
With ACA’s future in peril, California reins in rising health insurance premiums (California Healthline)
North Carolina uses new federal money to get people into drug treatment, but most of them are white (North Carolina Health News)
From The Hill’s opinion page
It’s time to end the senseless and cruel policy of cannabis criminalization